{ "schema_version": 8, "plugin_id": "agentic-course-redesign", "plugin_version": "0.2.4", "status": "candidate_not_active", "state_owner": "course_design_orchestrator", "umbrella_entry_routing": { "entry_name": "Agentic Course Redesign", "entry_skill": "course-redesign-orchestrator", "initial_gate": "GATE_0A_AWAITING_MATERIAL_ENVIRONMENT_ELIGIBILITY", "missing_project_action": "invoke_course-redesign-setup_preview_only", "gate_0a_required_before_any_course_source_path_filename_list_read_copy_hash_or_intake": true, "gate_0_required_before_course_source_reading": true, "gate_0_required_before_specialist_work": true }, "schema_compatibility": { "current_schema_version": 8, "minimum_preview_migration_source_version": 7, "migration_helper": "scripts/migrate_state_v7_to_v8.py", "migration_mode": "preview_only", "automatic_apply_forbidden": true, "preserve_during_preview": [ "status", "schedules", "active_run_id", "existing_run_ids_and_lineage", "source_manifest_and_access_policy", "run_and_schedule_history", "permissions_and_tool_egress_boundaries", "activation_and_schedule_registration_status" ], "migration_reconfirmation_requirements": [ "material_processing_eligibility", "every_nonterminal_run", "every_schedule_before_future_trigger" ] }, "adaptive_course_scope": { "supported_contexts": [ "school", "vocational_education_and_training", "professional_learning", "higher_education", "other_lecturer_defined" ], "adapt_to_supplied_material_context_level_learners_objectives_assessment_language_and_constraints": true, "subject_level_qualification_and_institutional_policy_assumptions_forbidden": true }, "material_processing_eligibility": { "schema_version": 1, "eligibility_id": null, "eligibility_version": 1, "status": "awaiting_lecturer_declaration", "allowed_statuses": [ "awaiting_lecturer_declaration", "approved", "route_only", "failed_closed" ], "gate": "GATE_0A_MATERIAL_ENVIRONMENT_ELIGIBILITY", "must_precede": [ "course_source_path_or_filename_disclosure", "course_source_listing", "course_source_read", "course_source_copy", "course_source_hash", "course_source_or_context_intake" ], "source_detail_prohibition_before_approval": [ "no_source_paths", "no_source_filenames", "no_source_lists", "no_source_content", "no_source_hashes" ], "environment": { "category": null, "allowed_categories": [ "personal_or_unmanaged", "approved_institutional_exact_environment" ], "exact_environment_reference": null, "institutional_policy_reference": null, "approved_scope": null, "policy_expires_at": null }, "material_scope": { "declared_category": null, "allowed_categories": [ "privately_owned_or_rightsholder_authorised", "appropriately_licensed_or_public_with_explicit_ai_processing_authority", "institution_internal_or_restricted", "mixed", "uncertain" ], "ai_processing_authority_confirmed": false, "public_availability_alone_is_insufficient": true, "contains_institution_internal_or_restricted_material": null, "contains_student_personal_data": null, "sensitivity_classification": null, "allowed_sensitivity_classifications": [ "non_sensitive", "institution_internal_or_restricted", "student_personal_data", "institution_internal_or_restricted_and_student_personal_data", "mixed_or_uncertain" ], "assessment_security_classification": null, "allowed_assessment_security_classifications": [ "no_protected_assessment_material", "contains_protected_assessment_or_answer_key_material", "mixed_or_uncertain" ], "assessment_security_handling_authorised": null }, "decision": { "outcome": null, "allowed_outcomes": [ "proceed", "route_only", "fail_closed_until_segregated", "fail_closed_until_clarified" ], "reason": null, "approved_processing_scope": null }, "fingerprint_method": "sha256_utf8_canonical_json_sorted_keys_no_insignificant_whitespace_excluding_fingerprint_and_approval_metadata", "fingerprint": null, "lecturer_declaration_reference": null, "recorded_at": null, "reconfirmation_required": true }, "course": { "title": null, "context": null, "level_and_programme": null, "learner_profile": null, "course_language": null, "grading_system": null, "timezone": null, "canonical_sources_confirmed": false, "educational_context_type": null, "discipline_or_subject": null, "qualification_or_framework": null, "adaptation_inputs_confirmed": false }, "source_manifest": null, "source_access_policy": { "status": "pending_lecturer_confirmation", "version": 0, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "fingerprint": null, "fingerprint_method": "sha256_utf8_canonical_json_sorted_keys_no_insignificant_whitespace", "fingerprint_payload": "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint_plus_version_per_source_classifications_role_tool_egress_permissions_output_audiences_and_exclusions_without_the_fingerprint_or_approval_metadata", "manifest_is_integrity_not_access_control": true, "allowed_source_classes": [ "student_safe", "lecturer_only_assessment", "licensed_restricted", "other_confidential", "excluded" ], "per_source_entries": [], "role_tool_egress_permissions": [], "allowed_output_audiences": [], "student_facing_outputs_exclude_lecturer_only_content": true, "assessment_security_smoke_test": { "status": "not_run", "checks": [ "rendered_visible_content", "editable_layers_and_text_boxes", "comments_and_notes", "metadata", "student_output_contains_no_answers_model_responses_or_teacher_only_content" ], "evidence_reference": null, "recorded_at": null }, "lecturer_approval_reference": null, "recorded_at": null }, "setup": { "mode": "linear_guided", "current_gate": "GATE_0A_AWAITING_MATERIAL_ENVIRONMENT_ELIGIBILITY", "next_permitted_action": "collect_category_only_gate_0a_declaration_without_source_paths_filenames_lists_content_or_hashes" }, "activation": { "allowed_statuses": [ "candidate_not_active", "active", "suspended" ], "validation_run_id": null, "required_before_active": [ "gate_0a_recorded", "gate_0_recorded", "gate_1_recorded", "gate_2a_recorded", "gate_2b_recorded", "source_manifest_verified", "source_access_policy_confirmed", "gate_3_blueprint_approved", "working_copy_test_approved", "production_completion_declared", "production_handoff_target_approved", "production_handoff_verified", "hitl_3_accepted", "system_improvement_review_offer_requested", "matching_course_run_terminal_complete_dormant", "system_update_approved", "read_only_smoke_test_passed", "assessment_security_smoke_test_passed", "separate_activation_decision_recorded" ], "system_update": { "status": "not_started", "allowed_statuses": [ "not_started", "proposal_requested", "proposal_presented", "candidate_change_approved", "validated" ], "prerequisites": [ "matching_run_production_completion_complete", "matching_run_production_handoff_verified", "matching_run_hitl_3_accepted", "matching_run_system_improvement_review_offer_requested", "matching_run_terminal_complete_dormant_and_not_active" ], "proposal_id": null, "proposal_version": null, "proposal_reference": null, "proposed_exact_targets": [], "required_standalone_line": "APPROVE SYSTEM FILES", "completed_reply_requirements": [ "validation_run_id", "run_id", "run_contract_id", "run_contract_version", "task_chat_reference", "shared_context_version", "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint", "source_manifest_fingerprint", "source_access_policy_version", "source_access_policy_fingerprint", "plan_version", "proposal_id", "proposal_version", "system_improvement_review_offer_reference", "all_exact_targets_match_visible_proposal", "APPROVE SYSTEM FILES_as_a_standalone_line" ], "approval": { "validation_run_id": null, "run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "standalone_line": null, "proposal_id": null, "proposal_version": null, "system_improvement_review_offer_reference": null, "approved_exact_targets": [], "completed_reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null }, "maximum_authorised_stage": "SYSTEM_GATE", "does_not_authorise_candidate_activation": true }, "separate_activation_decision": { "status": "not_requested", "allowed_statuses": [ "not_requested", "pending", "approved", "rejected" ], "required_matching_system_update_fields": [ "proposal_id", "proposal_version", "validation_evidence_reference", "residual_risks_reference", "rollback_reference" ], "validated_system_proposal_id": null, "validated_system_proposal_version": null, "validation_evidence_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "residual_risks_reference": null, "rollback_reference": null, "decision": null, "allowed_decisions": [ "activate_exact_validated_version", "keep_inactive", "revise_and_revalidate" ], "matching_rule": "approval_is_valid_only_when_proposal_id_and_version_match_activation.system_update_and_validation_status_is_passed", "lecturer_reply_reference": null, "prerequisites_verified_at": null, "recorded_at": null }, "automatic_activation_forbidden": true, "activated_at": null }, "schedule_registration": { "status": "not_approved", "required_active_runtime": { "status_path": "$.status", "status_must_equal": "active", "validated_system_proposal_id": null, "validated_system_proposal_version": null, "activation_decision_reference": null, "match_rule": "top_level_status_must_be_active_and_schedule_contract_runtime_id_and_version_must_match_the_separately_activated_validated_runtime" }, "required_material_processing_eligibility": { "fingerprint": null, "match_rule": "must_be_non_null_and_match_current_approved_gate_0a_before_simulation_registration_and_every_trigger", "change_requires_schedule_reconfirmation": true }, "required_completed_approval_lines": [ "APPROVE SCHEDULES", "Schedule contract: ", "Expires: " ], "no_write_simulation_status": "not_run", "no_write_simulation_result": null, "no_write_simulation_recorded_at": null, "no_immediate_run_required": true, "approved_standing_contract_ids": [], "approved_standing_contract_versions": [], "approval_reply_must_contain_exactly_and_only_the_three_lines": true, "approval": { "line_1": null, "line_2": null, "line_3": null, "parsed_contract_id": null, "parsed_contract_version": null, "parsed_expiry_local_with_iana_timezone": null, "completed_reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null } }, "active_run_id": null, "run_template": { "template_only": true, "run_id": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "mode": null, "allowed_modes": [ "manual", "scheduled" ], "trigger": { "trigger_id": null, "trigger_type": null, "allowed_trigger_types": [ "manual", "scheduled" ], "created_at": null, "creates_fresh_run_and_lineage": true, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "standing_schedule_contract_reference": null }, "status": "not_started", "allowed_run_statuses": [ "not_started", "active", "waiting_at_gate", "complete_dormant", "completed", "handed_off", "failed_safe", "cancelled", "expired" ], "started_at": null, "maximum_stage": null, "manual_stage_authority": { "transition_rules": [ { "trigger": "fresh_gate_1_approval", "authorises_through": "GATE_2A", "purpose": "preliminary_stage_a_only" }, { "trigger": "fresh_gate_2a_approval", "authorises_through": "GATE_2B", "purpose": "approved_full_research_and_exact_03_Research_dossier_handoff_approval_only" }, { "trigger": "fresh_blueprint_direction_after_gate_2b_decisions", "authorises_through": "GATE_3", "purpose": "interactive_blueprint_only" }, { "trigger": "fresh_gate_3_blueprint_and_exact_04_Working_Copies_and_05_Approved_material_targets_approval", "authorises_through": "PRODUCTION_HANDOFF", "purpose": "gated_artefact_production_and_handoff_only" }, { "trigger": "fresh_hitl3_acceptance_after_verified_production_handoff", "authorises_through": "SYSTEM_REVIEW_RESPONSE", "purpose": "materials_acceptance_and_mandatory_system_review_question_and_explicit_response_only", "does_not_authorise_candidate_activation": true }, { "trigger": "explicit_system_improvement_review_response", "authorises_through": "RUN_CLOSEOUT", "purpose": "record_requested_or_declined_then_close_course_run_complete_dormant", "requires_explicit_response": true, "silence_behavior": "remain_waiting_without_decision", "system_improvement_work_is_separate": true, "does_not_authorise_system_file_changes": true, "does_not_authorise_candidate_activation": true } ], "history_record_schema": { "from_maximum_stage": null, "to_maximum_stage": null, "trigger": null, "approval_reference": null, "recorded_at": null }, "history": [] }, "current_gate": "GATE_0A_AWAITING_MATERIAL_ENVIRONMENT_ELIGIBILITY", "execution_authority": { "current": null, "allowed": [ "lecturer_manual_direction", "standing_schedule_contract", "none" ], "standing_contract_reference": null, "fresh_lineage_required_for_every_trigger": true, "terminal_complete_dormant_never_resumes": true, "scheduled_authority_ends_at": "GATE_2B", "manual_continuation": { "status": "not_approved", "lecturer_direction": null, "approved_maximum_stage": null, "recorded_at": null } }, "contract": { "status": "pending_lecturer_approval", "contract_id": null, "version": 0, "standing_contract_reference": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "canonical_mission": "Together with the lecturer, produce the strongest defensible, evidence-informed, constructively aligned and feasible redesign of this specific course for its stated learners and context—improving meaningful learning and participation, purposeful AI competence, student experience and valid assessment while preserving worthwhile existing elements and respecting accessibility, workload, rights, privacy and institutional constraints. The lecturer retains every consequential pedagogical decision.", "main_goal": null, "non_goals": [], "success_criteria": [], "stop_conditions": [], "constraints": [], "permitted_tools": [], "permitted_actions": [], "approved_source_classes": [], "approved_output_audiences": [], "adaptation_inputs": { "educational_context_type": null, "discipline_or_subject": null, "learner_level": null, "objectives_framework": null, "assessment_model": null, "course_language": null, "constraints": [] }, "course_context_assumptions_forbidden": true, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "lecturer_reserved_assessment_decisions": [ "authoritative_current_objectives", "assessment_purpose_stakes_weight_and_completeness", "rubric_scoring_partial_credit_and_grade_conversion", "teacher_only_access_tool_egress_and_output_audience" ], "autonomy_bounds": { "may": [ "change_method_order_or_role_allocation_within_the_approved_goal_gate_scope_and_permissions", "revise_unfinished_downstream_subgoals_after_recorded_observations" ], "must_not": [ "change_main_goal_success_criteria_or_stop_conditions", "widen_scope_data_or_tool_permissions", "cross_a_gate_or_gain_write_authority", "reopen_a_settled_lecturer_decision" ] }, "lecturer_approval": { "status": "pending", "lecturer_reply": null, "recorded_at": null } }, "source_manifest_verification": { "manifest_path": null, "protected_roots": [ "00_Source_Materials", "00_Context" ], "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "status": "not_run", "verified_at": null, "changes_since_contract_approval": [] }, "approvals": { "gate_0a": { "approval_id": null, "status": "pending", "basis": "category_only_material_and_exact_processing_environment_declaration", "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "lecturer_declaration_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null }, "gate_0": { "approval_id": null, "status": "pending", "basis": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "lecturer_reply": null, "recorded_at": null, "approval_receipt": {"run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null} }, "gate_1": { "approval_id": null, "status": "pending", "basis": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "lecturer_reply": null, "recorded_at": null, "approval_receipt": {"run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null} }, "gate_2a": { "approval_id": null, "status": "not_started", "entry_preconditions_reference": "coordination.gate_2a_entry_requires", "lecturer_reply": null, "mission_interpretation": null, "approved_focus": [], "required_role_contract_fields": [ "role_goal", "subgoal_ids_2_to_5", "success_criteria", "dependencies", "replan_triggers", "lecturer_decision" ], "role_contracts": [], "recorded_at": null, "approval_receipt": {"run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null} }, "gate_2b": { "approval_id": null, "status": "not_started", "lecturer_reply": null, "selected_change_cards": [], "approved_research_targets": [], "research_target_record_schema": { "target_type": null, "relative_path": null, "run_id": null, "approved_at": null }, "target_rules": { "required_prefix": "03_Research/", "required_dated_run_folder_pattern": "^03_Research/[0-9]{4}-[0-9]{2}-[0-9]{2}_[A-Za-z0-9._-]+/[^/]+$", "allowed_target_types": [ "research_dossier", "research_handoff" ], "required_target_types_when_approved": [ "research_dossier", "research_handoff" ], "forbidden_prefixes": [ "04_Working_Copies/", "05_Approved/" ], "course_material_production_authorised": false }, "recorded_at": null, "approval_receipt": {"run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null} }, "gate_3": { "approval_id": null, "status": "not_started", "lecturer_reply": null, "approved_blueprint_reference": null, "approved_material_targets": [], "material_target_record_schema": { "target_type": null, "relative_path": null, "audience_classification": null, "run_id": null, "approved_at": null }, "target_rules": { "type_prefix_map": { "working_copy": "04_Working_Copies/", "approved_release": "05_Approved/" }, "research_prefix_forbidden": "03_Research/", "exact_targets_required_before_production": true, "gate_2b_research_target_approval_is_not_material_write_authority": true }, "recorded_at": null, "approval_receipt": {"run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null} }, "artefact_gate": { "approval_id": null, "status": "not_started", "artefacts": [], "approval_receipt": {"run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null} }, "production_completion": { "status": "not_started", "allowed_statuses": [ "not_started", "awaiting_declaration", "declared_awaiting_handoff_approval", "handoff_approved_awaiting_verification", "complete" ], "required_matching_lineage_fields": [ "run_id", "run_contract_id", "run_contract_version", "task_chat_reference", "shared_context_version", "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint", "source_manifest_fingerprint", "source_access_policy_version", "source_access_policy_fingerprint", "plan_version" ], "declaration": { "required_standalone_line": "DECLARE PRODUCTION COMPLETE", "completed_reply": { "run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "standalone_line": null, "reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null } }, "handoff_approval": { "required_standalone_line": "APPROVE PRODUCTION HANDOFF", "exact_handoff_target": null, "completed_reply": { "run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "repeated_exact_handoff_target": null, "standalone_line": null, "reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null } }, "handoff_verified_at": null }, "hitl_3": { "status": "not_started", "allowed_statuses": [ "not_started", "awaiting_lecturer_decision", "revision_requested", "conditional_acceptance_pending_verification", "accepted", "rejected" ], "entry_requires": [ "production_completion.status_is_complete", "production_completion.declaration.completed_reply.validation_status_is_passed", "production_completion.handoff_approval.completed_reply.validation_status_is_passed", "production_completion.handoff_verified_at_is_non_null" ], "required_matching_lineage_fields": [ "run_id", "run_contract_id", "run_contract_version", "task_chat_reference", "shared_context_version", "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint", "source_manifest_fingerprint", "source_access_policy_version", "source_access_policy_fingerprint", "plan_version" ], "decision": { "run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "decision": null, "allowed_decisions": [ "accept", "conditionally_accept_named_corrections", "request_revision", "reject" ], "named_corrections": [], "corrections_verification_reference": null, "final_acceptance_reference": null, "reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null } }, "system_improvement_review_offer": { "status": "not_offered", "allowed_statuses": [ "not_offered", "offered_awaiting_response", "requested", "declined" ], "entry_requires": [ "hitl_3.status_is_accepted", "hitl_3.decision.validation_status_is_passed", "hitl_3.decision.final_acceptance_reference_is_non_null", "current_lineage_matches" ], "mandatory_question": "Would you like a separate, read-only system-improvement review covering the workflow skills and umbrella entry routing; plugin or platform adapter; AGENTS.md and agent configurations; project template, state schema and migration; validators, tests and QA; documentation; memory or other workflow-owned durable instruction stores; schedule contracts; permissions, tools, external egress and automatic behaviour; and compatibility, benefits, regressions, risks, residual risks and rollback, followed only by a versioned proposal? A yes authorises only that review and proposal; it does not authorise system-file changes, installation, publication or release, runtime activation, schedule registration or modification, an immediate run, or any added MCP server, connector, authentication, permission or external egress.", "required_question_scope": [ "workflow_skills_and_umbrella_entry_routing", "plugin_or_platform_adapter", "AGENTS_md_and_agent_configurations", "project_template_state_schema_and_migration", "validators_tests_and_quality_assurance", "documentation", "memory_or_other_workflow_owned_durable_instruction_stores", "schedule_contracts", "permissions_tools_external_egress_and_automatic_behaviour", "compatibility_benefits_regressions_risks_residual_risks_and_rollback" ], "ask_exactly_once": true, "record_offer_before_asking": true, "idempotency_key_fields": [ "run_id", "hitl_3_final_acceptance_reference" ], "offer": { "offer_id": null, "run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "hitl_3_final_acceptance_reference": null, "question_scope_presented": [], "question_text": null, "offer_reference": null, "offered_at": null, "validation_status": "not_run" }, "response": { "run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "decision": null, "allowed_decisions": [ "request_read_only_system_improvement_review_and_versioned_proposal", "decline_system_improvement_review" ], "reply_reference": null, "responded_at": null, "validation_status": "not_run" }, "resume_behavior": { "not_offered": "ask_once_only_after_prerequisites_pass_and_persist_offer_first", "offered_awaiting_response": "resume_wait_without_reasking", "requested": "close_course_run_complete_dormant_then_continue_separate_read_only_system_work_without_reasking", "declined": "close_course_run_complete_dormant_without_system_action_and_do_not_reask", "silence": "remain_waiting_and_record_no_decision", "lineage_mismatch": "fail_closed_and_request_reconfirmation" }, "authority_on_request": { "authorises": [ "read_only_review_of_current_system_and_successful_run_evidence", "prepare_one_versioned_system_improvement_proposal" ], "does_not_authorise": [ "create_or_modify_system_files", "install_or_update_plugin", "publish_or_release", "activate_runtime", "register_or_modify_schedule", "trigger_immediate_run", "add_mcp_server_connector_authentication_permission_or_external_egress" ], "candidate_file_changes_require": "separate_system_gate_with_APPROVE SYSTEM FILES", "activation_requires": "later_separate_activation_decision", "schedule_requires": "active_matching_runtime_plus_no_write_simulation_and_separate_expiring_schedule_approval", "course_run_must_close_before_separate_system_work": true } }, "trigger_guidance_offer": { "status": "not_offered", "allowed_statuses": [ "not_offered", "offered" ], "entry_requires": [ "system_improvement_review_offer.status_is_requested_or_declined", "run.status_is_complete_dormant", "termination.status_is_complete_dormant", "top_level_active_run_id_is_cleared" ], "offer_exactly_once": true, "informational_only": true, "manual_trigger_guidance": "manual_trigger_available_and_always_creates_fresh_run_and_lineage_bound_to_current_eligibility_fingerprint", "optional_schedule_guidance": { "requires_exact_fields": [ "course", "project", "iana_timezone", "recurrence", "non_null_expiry" ], "requires_separate_system_activation_simulation_and_schedule_gates": true, "no_immediate_run": true, "each_recurrence_creates_fresh_run_and_lineage": true }, "offer": { "offer_id": null, "run_id": null, "system_improvement_response_reference": null, "offer_reference": null, "offered_at": null, "validation_status": "not_run" } } }, "resume_protocol": { "schema_version": 1, "checkpoint_order": [ "approvals.production_completion.declaration", "approvals.production_completion.handoff_approval", "approvals.production_completion.handoff_verified_at", "approvals.hitl_3", "approvals.system_improvement_review_offer", "termination.status", "approvals.trigger_guidance_offer" ], "receipt_reference_fields": [ "approvals.production_completion.declaration.completed_reply.reply_reference", "approvals.production_completion.handoff_approval.completed_reply.reply_reference", "approvals.production_completion.handoff_verified_at", "approvals.hitl_3.decision.final_acceptance_reference", "approvals.system_improvement_review_offer.offer.offer_reference", "approvals.system_improvement_review_offer.response.reply_reference", "termination.recorded_at", "approvals.trigger_guidance_offer.offer.offer_reference" ], "rules": { "persist_receipt_before_advancing_next_permitted_action": true, "same_receipt_reference_is_idempotent": true, "completed_checkpoint_must_not_repeat": true, "resume_from_first_incomplete_checkpoint": true, "current_lineage_required_before_resume": true, "lineage_mismatch_fails_closed": true, "silence_is_not_a_system_improvement_decision": true, "complete_dormant_is_terminal_and_never_resumable": true } }, "shared_context": { "version": 0, "old_course_brief_reference": null, "canonical_source_snapshot": [], "declared_objectives": [], "taught_or_inferred_outcomes": [], "assessment_artifact_inventory": [], "assessment_completeness_status": null, "missing_assessment_artifacts_or_rules": [], "alignment_ledger_reference": null, "lecturer_only_assessment_questions": [], "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "lecturer_decisions": [], "open_risks": [], "payload_location": "task_chat_until_exact_target_approval", "updated_at": null }, "plan_version": 0, "goal_tree": { "root": { "id": "RUN_MAIN_GOAL", "owner": "course_design_orchestrator", "goal_reference": "contract.main_goal", "status": "not_started", "completion_criteria_reference": "contract.success_criteria" }, "role_subgoal_count_per_active_round": { "minimum": 2, "maximum": 5 }, "role_branches": [ { "id": "ORCHESTRATION", "owner": "course_design_orchestrator", "role_goal": "Coordinate safe progress toward the approved run goal while preserving shared state, dependencies, gates and lecturer decisions.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": [], "gate_dependencies": [], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] }, { "id": "COURSE_MAPPING", "owner": "course_mapper", "role_goal": "Produce a source-grounded map from stated and inferred outcomes to introduction, practice and assessment items, with source status, gaps and uncertainty explicit.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": [], "gate_dependencies": ["gate_1"], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] }, { "id": "ACTIVE_LEARNING", "owner": "active_learning_researcher", "role_goal": "Develop feasible active-learning options from the approved outcome-practice-assessment map without reusing teacher-only answer content, with evidence, workload and accessible low-tech alternatives.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": [], "gate_dependencies": ["gate_1"], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] }, { "id": "AI_INTEGRATION", "owner": "ai_integration_researcher", "role_goal": "Develop purposeful AI-competence and non-AI options within approved source-class, tool, egress, assessment-security, transparency and validity boundaries.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": [], "gate_dependencies": ["gate_1"], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] }, { "id": "STUDENT_EXPERIENCE_PROXY", "owner": "student_experience_critic", "role_goal": "Act as a bounded design-review proxy for clarity, workload, accessibility, inclusion and fairness without claiming to represent students.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": [], "gate_dependencies": ["gate_1"], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] }, { "id": "ASSESSMENT_LEDGER", "owner": "assessment_alignment_designer", "role_goal": "Own the live outcome-introduction/practice-assessment ledger from the first scan, qualify dated or partial evidence, audit coverage/demand/points/criteria/security and keep integration current as findings arrive.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": [], "gate_dependencies": ["gate_1"], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] }, { "id": "ASSESSMENT_FINAL_INTEGRATION", "owner": "assessment_alignment_designer", "role_goal": "Integrate assessment and constructive alignment last after all other specialist reports and relays are complete, preserving partial-evidence qualifications and teacher/student output boundaries.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": [ "COURSE_MAPPING", "ACTIVE_LEARNING", "AI_INTEGRATION", "STUDENT_EXPERIENCE_PROXY", "ASSESSMENT_LEDGER" ], "gate_dependencies": ["gate_2a"], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] }, { "id": "SOURCE_VERIFICATION", "owner": "source_verification_citation_auditor", "role_goal": "Independently verify consequential claims, primary source artefacts, dates, citations, links and the separate rights boundary before Gate 2B and after consequential source corrections.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": [ "COURSE_MAPPING", "ACTIVE_LEARNING", "AI_INTEGRATION", "STUDENT_EXPERIENCE_PROXY", "ASSESSMENT_LEDGER" ], "gate_dependencies": ["gate_2a"], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] }, { "id": "RED_TEAM", "owner": "evidence_feasibility_red_team", "role_goal": "Independently test the integrated dossier and block Gate 2B recommendation while any material defect remains.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": ["ASSESSMENT_FINAL_INTEGRATION", "SOURCE_VERIFICATION"], "gate_dependencies": ["gate_2a"], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] }, { "id": "BLUEPRINT", "owner": "learning_designer", "role_goal": "Guide lecturer decisions into one coherent, ledger-tested blueprint with unresolved risks exposed.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": ["RED_TEAM"], "gate_dependencies": ["gate_2b"], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] }, { "id": "PRODUCTION", "owner": "learning_material_designer", "role_goal": "Return exact-target, audience-classified artefact proposals and reproducible QA, including no-answer-leakage evidence for student-facing assessment files, without changing protected sources or exceeding write authority.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": ["BLUEPRINT"], "gate_dependencies": ["gate_3"], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] }, { "id": "ARTEFACT_INDEPENDENT_QA", "owner": "artefact_accessibility_visual_qa", "role_goal": "Independently reopen, render and audit exact artefacts for blueprint fidelity, accessibility, visual quality, security, links, package integrity and cross-file consistency.", "status": "not_started", "depends_on": ["PRODUCTION"], "gate_dependencies": ["gate_3"], "permitted_actions": [], "completion_criteria": [], "subgoals": [] } ], "open_dependencies": [] }, "coordination": { "state_capsule_version": 0, "shared_brief_confirmed": false, "all_five_first_scan_started": false, "stage_a_role_statuses": [ {"role_id": "course_mapper", "status": "not_started", "accepted_return_id": null}, {"role_id": "active_learning_researcher", "status": "not_started", "accepted_return_id": null}, {"role_id": "ai_integration_researcher", "status": "not_started", "accepted_return_id": null}, {"role_id": "student_experience_critic", "status": "not_started", "accepted_return_id": null}, {"role_id": "assessment_alignment_designer", "status": "not_started", "accepted_return_id": null} ], "allowed_stage_a_role_statuses": ["not_started", "running", "complete_accepted", "blocked"], "all_five_stage_a_complete": false, "gate_2a_entry_requires": [ "all_five_stage_a_role_statuses_are_complete_accepted", "each_role_has_one_current_lineage_accepted_return_id", "preliminary_summary_exchange_complete", "live_alignment_ledger_started" ], "preliminary_summary_exchange_complete": false, "live_alignment_ledger_started": false, "cross_review_complete": false, "assessment_final_integration_complete": false, "red_team_complete": false }, "specialist_return_envelope": { "schema_version": 1, "required_fields": [ "return_id", "run_id", "run_contract_id", "run_contract_version", "task_chat_reference", "shared_context_version", "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint", "source_manifest_fingerprint", "source_access_policy_version", "source_access_policy_fingerprint", "source_classes_used", "output_audience_classification", "assessment_security_implications", "plan_version", "role_id", "stage_id", "subgoal_ids", "status", "findings_and_proposed_actions", "claims", "alignment_ledger_implications", "dependencies_overlaps_conflicts", "assumptions", "lecturer_only_questions", "risks", "criteria_met", "criteria_unmet", "scope_and_completion_check", "dependency_changes", "proposed_replan", "escalation_needed", "recommended_next_action", "retry_state" ], "allowed_statuses": [ "complete", "partial", "blocked" ], "task_chat_reference_rule": "required_when_runtime_exposes_one_otherwise_null_with_limit_stated", "claims_item_fields": [ "claim", "source", "confidence", "limitations" ], "lineage_must_match_current_state": [ "run_id", "run_contract_id", "run_contract_version", "task_chat_reference_when_present", "shared_context_version", "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint", "source_manifest_fingerprint", "source_access_policy_version", "source_access_policy_fingerprint", "plan_version" ], "mismatch_action": "reject_without_merge_record_rejection_and_escalate", "record_schema": { "return_id": null, "run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "source_classes_used": [], "output_audience_classification": null, "assessment_security_implications": [], "plan_version": null, "role_id": null, "stage_id": null, "subgoal_ids": [], "status": null, "retry_number": 0, "retry_state": { "retries_used": 0, "retries_remaining": 1, "retry_reason": null }, "payload_reference": null, "validation_status": null, "received_at": null }, "accepted_return_records": [], "rejected_return_records": [], "invalidated_return_records_after_approved_context_change": [] }, "retry_policy": { "max_retries_per_specialist_per_stage": 1, "counter_key_fields": [ "role_id", "stage_id" ], "counter_record_schema": { "role_id": null, "stage_id": null, "retries_used": 0, "retries_remaining": 1 }, "counters": [], "retryable_reasons": [ "incomplete_return_envelope", "unsupported_claim", "resolvable_specialist_conflict", "correctable_role_output_failure", "lecturer_confirmed_context_invalidation" ], "history_record_schema": { "retry_id": null, "run_id": null, "run_contract_id": null, "run_contract_version": null, "task_chat_reference": null, "role_id": null, "stage_id": null, "retry_number": 1, "reason": null, "shared_context_version": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "plan_version": null, "corrective_scope": null, "outcome": null, "escalation_reference": null, "recorded_at": null }, "history": [], "on_failed_retry": "record_escalation_stop_affected_branch_and_request_lecturer_or_missing_evidence_decision", "replanning_never_resets_retry_counter": true }, "observations": [], "replan_history": [], "escalations": [], "evaluation": { "status": "not_started", "success_criteria_met": [], "success_criteria_unmet": [], "residual_risks": [], "last_evaluated_at": null }, "next_permitted_action": "validate_current_gate_0a_eligibility_fingerprint_before_any_source_disclosure_or_access", "awaited_lecturer_decision": null, "handoff": { "latest_path": null, "verified_at": null }, "termination": { "allowed_statuses": [ "complete_dormant", "completed", "handed_off", "failed_safe", "cancelled", "expired" ], "status": null, "reason": null, "recorded_at": null, "system_improvement_response_reference": null, "active_run_id_cleared_at": null, "never_resume_after_terminal": true, "closeout_requires_explicit_system_improvement_response": true, "silence_remains_waiting": true } }, "runs": [], "standing_schedule_contract_template": { "contract_id": null, "contract_version": null, "status": "not_approved", "allowed_statuses": [ "not_approved", "active", "paused", "expired", "cancelled" ], "project": { "project_id": null, "project_root": null }, "course": { "course_id": null, "course_title": null }, "task_type": "standalone_fresh_task_per_run", "runtime_versions": { "prompt_version": null, "skill_name": "course-redesign-orchestrator", "skill_version": null, "validated_system_proposal_id": null, "validated_system_proposal_version": null, "activation_decision_reference": null, "required_runtime_status": "active", "match_rule": "values_must_match_activation.separate_activation_decision_and_top_level_status_active" }, "baseline_approvals": { "gate_0a_approval_id": null, "gate_0_approval_id": null, "gate_1_approval_id": null, "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "source_manifest_path": null, "source_manifest_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "verified_still_valid_at": null, "verification_result": null }, "canonical_mission": "Together with the lecturer, produce the strongest defensible, evidence-informed, constructively aligned and feasible redesign of this specific course for its stated learners and context—improving meaningful learning and participation, purposeful AI competence, student experience and valid assessment while preserving worthwhile existing elements and respecting accessibility, workload, rights, privacy and institutional constraints. The lecturer retains every consequential pedagogical decision.", "main_goal": null, "non_goals": [], "success_criteria": [], "stop_conditions": [], "constraints": [], "permitted_tools": [], "permitted_actions": [], "data_egress_boundary": null, "permitted_source_classes": [], "permitted_output_audiences": [], "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint": null, "material_processing_eligibility_match_rule": "must_be_non_null_and_match_current_approved_gate_0a_before_simulation_registration_and_every_recurrence", "source_access_policy_version": null, "source_access_policy_fingerprint": null, "source_access_policy_match_rule": "version_and_fingerprint_must_be_non_null_and_match_current_lecturer_confirmed_policy_before_registration_and_every_recurrence", "assessment_security_boundary": null, "protected_roots": [ "00_Source_Materials", "00_Context" ], "timezone": null, "timezone_requires_lecturer_confirmation": true, "recurrence": [], "permitted_actions_before_gate_2a": [ "create_fresh_run_metadata", "create_fresh_trigger_id_run_id_and_lineage_with_current_material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint", "validate_current_gate_0a_material_processing_eligibility", "validate_standing_contract_and_reconfirmation_triggers", "verify_source_manifest", "verify_current_lecturer_confirmed_source_access_policy", "perform_all_five_preliminary_scan_including_assessment_ledger", "present_gate_2a_mission_role_contracts_and_focus" ], "permitted_actions_after_fresh_gate_2a_approval": [ "perform_approved_full_research_chat_only", "cross_review_and_relay", "assessment_final_integration", "red_team_audit", "present_gate_2b_change_cards_and_exact_proposed_targets" ], "permitted_actions_after_fresh_gate_2b_target_approval": [ "write_only_lecturer_approved_exact_research_dossier_and_research_handoff_targets_under_03_Research", "do_not_produce_course_materials_or_write_under_04_Working_Copies_or_05_Approved", "wait_at_gate_2b_and_end_schedule_authority" ], "write_authority": "research_dossier_and_research_handoff_under_03_Research_only_after_that_run_has_gate_2b_exact_research_target_approval", "no_write_before_exact_target_approval": true, "unique_output_naming_rule": "new_unique_03_Research/YYYY-MM-DD_/folder_per_run_no_overwrite_or_append", "first_required_wait": "GATE_2A", "maximum_stage": "GATE_2B", "retry_rules": { "max_retries_per_specialist_per_stage": 1, "counter_source": "active_run.retry_policy", "on_failed_retry": "escalate_and_stop_affected_branch" }, "escalation_rules": [ "missing_or_stale_baseline", "source_manifest_or_context_mismatch", "missing_evidence_or_repeated_failure", "rights_privacy_or_data_egress_uncertainty", "scope_change_or_lecturer_reserved_decision" ], "terminal_rules": { "allowed": [ "complete_dormant", "completed", "handed_off", "failed_safe", "cancelled", "expired" ], "on_or_after_expiry": "return_expired_without_course_action" }, "no_immediate_run": true, "approved_contract_snapshot_reference": null, "approved_at": null, "activation_time": null, "expires_at": null, "activation_requires_non_null_expires_at": true, "required_completed_approval_lines": [ "APPROVE SCHEDULES", "Schedule contract: ", "Expires: " ], "last_reconfirmed_at": null, "reconfirmation_history": [], "expiry_behavior": "mark_contract_and_triggered_run_expired_without_course_analysis", "stale_baseline_context_or_manifest_behavior": "mark_triggered_run_failed_safe_stop_and_request_lecturer_reconfirmation", "reconfirmation_triggers": [ "contract_expiry", "material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint_or_environment_policy_scope_expiry_change", "canonical_source_or_hash_change", "course_context_outcome_or_assessment_change", "objective_test_key_rubric_or_source_classification_change", "source_access_role_tool_egress_or_output_audience_change", "data_classification_rights_or_institutional_policy_change", "approved_tool_or_data_egress_change", "schedule_scope_or_autonomy_bound_change" ], "pause": { "requires_lecturer_direction": true, "action": "disable_future_triggers_preserve_contract_and_run_history", "status": "available", "lecturer_direction_reference": null, "paused_at": null }, "renew": { "status": "not_requested", "requires_new_contract_version": true, "requires_new_expiry": true, "requires_no_write_simulation": true, "requires_all_three_completed_approval_lines": true, "renewal_history": [] }, "rollback": { "status": "not_requested", "requires_lecturer_direction": true, "action": "disable_schedule_restore_last_approved_contract_snapshot_and_preserve_run_history", "rollback_reference": null, "rolled_back_at": null }, "activation_requires": [ "contract_id_and_version", "active_runtime_status_and_matching_validated_system_proposal_id_version", "project_course_and_standalone_task_type", "prompt_and_skill_versions", "still_valid_gate_0a_gate_0_and_gate_1_approval_ids", "non_null_current_material_processing_eligibility_fingerprint", "timezone_recurrence_activation_time_and_expiry", "permitted_tools_actions_and_data_egress_boundary", "non_null_matching_source_access_policy_version_fingerprint_source_classes_output_audiences_and_assessment_security_boundary", "protected_root_and_exact_write_boundary", "gate_2a_first_wait_and_gate_2b_maximum", "retry_escalation_and_terminal_rules", "pause_renew_rollback_and_no_immediate_run", "successful_no_write_simulation", "three_matching_completed_approval_lines" ], "lecturer_approval": { "status": "pending", "reply_must_contain_exactly_and_only_three_lines": true, "line_1": null, "line_2": null, "line_3": null, "completed_reply_reference": null, "validation_status": "not_run", "recorded_at": null }, "status_transition_receipt": { "status": null, "allowed_statuses": [ "paused", "expired", "cancelled" ], "reason": null, "decision_or_detection_reference": null, "recorded_at": null, "future_triggers_disabled": null, "no_course_action": null, "triggered_run_id": null, "preserved_contract_snapshot_reference": null }, "status_history": [] }, "open_questions": [ "Before disclosing any source detail, which material category and exact processing-environment category apply for Gate 0A?", "Which learning-objectives file/version is authoritative and current?", "What is the current assessment status, purpose, stakes, weighting, grading conversion and pass rule?", "Are all supplied assessment files complete, and which are student-facing versus lecturer-only?", "What rubrics, acceptable-answer guidance and partial-credit rules apply?", "Which roles and tools may access each protected source class, may any content leave the device, and which output audiences are permitted?", "Which IANA timezone and, if later approved, recurrence and expiry should a standing schedule use?" ], "schedules": [] }