{"id":47509,"plugin_id":"plugins_6abdca92a1908191b989544ed495ca16","kind":"skill","collection_source":"plugin_package","comparison_source":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-24T13:33:35.434Z","digest":"6122dc60b3b258ecb3cd0647b87a660474fe988c0b222bb583e1153c6fd19ef8","against":null,"payload":{"description":"Dialectical clarity, argument red team, persuasion, evidence provenance, adversarial evidence review, and assuring/guarding/discounting move analysis. Use when the user requests one of these focused audits. For the complete audit catalog or an unclear request, use specialized-audits.\n","included_files":[{"relative_path":"references/craft/adversarial-evidence-review.md","size_in_bytes":35446},{"relative_path":"references/craft/argument-agd-audit.md","size_in_bytes":15138},{"relative_path":"references/craft/argument-evidence.md","size_in_bytes":12687},{"relative_path":"references/craft/argument-persuasion-level-setting.md","size_in_bytes":11251},{"relative_path":"references/craft/argument-persuasion.md","size_in_bytes":11585},{"relative_path":"references/craft/argument-red-team-level-setting.md","size_in_bytes":32732},{"relative_path":"references/craft/argument-red-team.md","size_in_bytes":24415},{"relative_path":"references/craft/dialectical-clarity-level-setting.md","size_in_bytes":40412},{"relative_path":"references/craft/dialectical-clarity.md","size_in_bytes":107592},{"relative_path":"references/craft/rhetorical-stance-triage.md","size_in_bytes":4190}],"name":"argument-audits","skill_md_contents":"---\nname: argument-audits\ndescription: >\n  Dialectical clarity, argument red team, persuasion, evidence provenance, adversarial evidence review, and assuring/guarding/discounting move analysis.\n  Use when the user requests one of these focused audits. For the complete\n  audit catalog or an unclear request, use specialized-audits.\nversion: 2.13.3\n---\n\n# Argument Analysis\n\nLoad `../core-editor/references/focused-audit-contract.md` for the shared execution, output, and severity contract.\nSelect the requested protocol below and read it in full. Load its named\ncompanions and level-setting references when called for; do not load every\nprotocol in this family. Preserve all flags, gates, register/genre calibrations,\nprerequisites and claim limits in the selected protocol. This skill diagnoses;\nit does not rewrite manuscript prose.\n\nPaths beginning `references/` or `scripts/` in these protocols resolve from\nthis skill directory. Paths naming another skill resolve from the shared\n`skills/` directory; `../` links resolve from this skill directory.\n\n| Request / command alias | Task | Protocol |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| `dialectical` | **Dialectical Clarity** — argument structure, rhetorical fairness | `references/craft/dialectical-clarity.md` |\n| `argument-red-team` | **Argument Red Team** — Hostile-reader simulation | `references/craft/argument-red-team.md` |\n| `argument-persuasion` | **Argument Persuasion** — Audience matrix & framing | `references/craft/argument-persuasion.md` |\n| `argument-evidence` | **Argument Evidence Deep-Dive** — Provenance & testimony calibration | `references/craft/argument-evidence.md` |\n| `adversarial-evidence-review` | **Adversarial Evidence Review** — Evidence survivability under structured adversarial protocols | `references/craft/adversarial-evidence-review.md` |\n| `argument-agd` | **AGD Move Audit** — Functional assuring, guarding, and discounting move audit | `references/craft/argument-agd-audit.md` |\n\n## Prerequisites and handoffs\n\nDialectical Clarity produces `Argument_State.md`; companion analyses consume\nthat populated state for the same draft. This family implements focused argument\naudits; `../nonfiction-argument-engine/SKILL.md` owns full-run intake and orchestration.\nAdversarial Evidence Review also requires the evidence ledger, citation ledger,\nand field-reconnaissance report specified by its protocol. Research requests\nroute to `../research-verification/SKILL.md`. The optional AGD mechanical scan\nis `../prose-measurements/scripts/ai_prose_agd_move_scan.py`; only this family's\nAGD protocol adjudicates the scan's candidate pointers.\n"},"changes":[],"summary":"First saved snapshot. No earlier version is available for comparison.","summary_kind":"deterministic","summary_metadata":{}}