skills/ce-brainstorm/references/bakeoff.md

# Bake-off in brainstorming

Use `ce-bakeoff` only when explicitly requested and the need and constraints are clear enough to develop competing product mechanisms. If the goal itself is unsettled, finish discovery first. Preserve specific settled decisions; do not invent a fork to satisfy the request.

Resolve model preferences using the activation-resolution rules in `references/reasoning-elevation.md`. Pass the resolved preference, including explicit restrictions, to `ce-bakeoff` with the full grounding dossier, relevant dialogue and constraints, the specific question, settled decisions, budget, and product-mechanism fidelity. An explicit candidate model mix takes precedence. Bake-off owns fresh candidate dispatch and fallback; do not run the ordinary generation adapter for each baker. With no preference, allow Bake-off's default model-family exploration.

This replaces the ordinary generation call for the selected question. The session orchestrator dispatches and persists the returned artifacts; read-only elevated authors do neither. Do not produce an ordinary approach set before or after the competition for the same question.

Bake-off selects a recommendation, not a user-approved Product Contract. Return to Phase 2 with the complete result, present viable options before the recommendation, and preserve the existing product-altitude, experiential-choice, and scope-confirmation rules. Keep incomplete or unresolved outcomes visible; obtain the missing product input when it prevents a defensible recommendation. Incorporate the decision record into the existing artifact rather than create another canonical plan.