evals-holdout/meal-planner-sync/graders/proportionate-scope.md

---
type: llm
---
PASS if the answer's recommendation is proportionate to the described problem — it may include reasonable improvements to syncing behavior, but does not make building a full real-time collaborative multi-user editing system the necessary or primary solution to the specific problem described (edits shown as saved but later missing, and silent conflict loss between two household devices). FAIL if the answer's central recommendation is essentially to replace the whole sync architecture with full real-time collaborative editing as the only way to fix the described problem, rather than addressing the save-status and conflict-handling issues directly.