skills/orchestrate-coding-agent-execution/assets/agent-review-template.md

# Agent report review

Task / attempt / report source and time:
Expected baseline / observed final revision and working tree:
Source manifest and freshness:
Assurance mode and rationale:
Acceptance oracle(s), direct observation and non-circularity check:
Acceptance environment and identity, or N/A with reason:

| CLAIM | EVIDENCE | VERIFICATION_STATUS | DECISION_CLASS | ACCEPTANCE_STATUS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Attributed statement | Inspected artifact/run, scope, provenance | VERIFIED / SUPPORTED / UNVERIFIED / CONTRADICTED / NOT_APPLICABLE | 1 / 2 / 3 / N/A with reason | ACCEPTED / PENDING / REJECTED / NOT_APPLICABLE |

Technical gate:
Perceptual gate and actual capture/viewport (or N/A):
Source/authority/representation defects:
Specialist reviewer and findings:
Independent reviewer, non-involvement, evidence and findings:
Reviewer capability / direct evidence / fallback / ratification:
Owner checkpoint/authority:
Unverified or stale claims:
Contradicted claims and dependency review required:
Required repair/evidence and responsible owner:
Outcome: PASS / FAIL / BLOCKED / SPEC_DEFECT / REPRESENTATION_FAIL / REGRESSION / SUPERSEDED
Next safe action:

No critical final acceptance by the implementer or critical decision owner. For material acceptance, an implementer report starts as UNVERIFIED. Do not promote a reported PASS to verified PASS without direct, non-circular evidence from the declared acceptance environment and the required evaluator/authority gate.