evals/conflicts/equal-confidence-contradiction.json

{
  "scenario_id": "CNF-008",
  "name": "equal_confidence_contradiction",
  "description": "Director receives two contradictory recommendations with equal confidence and equal priority; Director enforces safety default and queries user if unresolved.",
  "existing_locks": [],
  "incoming_decisions": [
    {
      "key": "composition_state.layout_balance",
      "value": "Asymmetric left-heavy dynamic balance",
      "rationale": "Recommended by Structure Critic",
      "priority": 5
    },
    {
      "key": "composition_state.layout_balance",
      "value": "Centered classical symmetry",
      "rationale": "Recommended by Brand Guardian for luxury tier",
      "priority": 5
    }
  ],
  "expected_outcome": {
    "decision_applied": true,
    "winning_lock_priority": 5,
    "lock_preserved": "Asymmetric left-heavy dynamic balance"
  }
}